Company car vs mileage

Share This Guide, Choose Your Platform!

Introduction -contractor company car vs mileage allowance 

As a UK limited company contractor, let’s compare the costs of a contractor company car vs mileage allowance in your own vehicle for business journeys. Certainly, many UK contractors consider should I get a company car (UK) and how much tax do I pay on a company car? Indeed, company car vs mileage reimbursement is key when looking for company car advice as a UK contracting professional. As a contractor, when incurring company mileage, you can use your own car and claim mileage allowances from your business. However, nowadays more contractors are choosing a company car. In this guide, we’ll compare company car versus mileage to give you better insight on which is best. Importantly, for a company vehicle to be beneficial, we should look at tax-efficient company cars.

First, how do tax savings compare for a contractor company car or mileage reimbursement for your private vehicle use? Basically, what should we consider in both scenarios? What’s more, how much is company car tax when you’re contracting? Furthermore, what’s the overall savings of a company vehicle? In this guide, we’ll see how much tax you’ll pay personally, when running one and incurring company car private mileage. As a result, we can compare this to the savings when you’re claiming mileage as a contractor for your private vehicle.

When you’ve a company vehicle, it has advantages and disadvantages. Indeed, the tax savings and running costs depend on the type of contractor car you use. Also, this depends on how many miles you travel in the vehicle. When searching the best work vehicles for contractors in terms of tax efficiency, your contractor accountant can help. Basically, if you can provide them the specific details of the vehicle, they can work out the tax position in terms of tax-efficient company contractor cars.

Initial thoughts -company car vs mileage allowance 

What to think about first

In most cases, UK limited company contractors will travel to work each day by car. However, since the pandemic some now spend more time working from home.

The journeys by contractors who travel to work by car will consist of visiting their main client site(s). Furthermore, business journeys by car could include:

  • Visits to other work-type sites.
  • To attend training sessions.
  • Attend conferences and seminars.

Common questions 

There’ll be common questions from UK contractors and business owners alike regarding how they travel to work. Indeed, when they’re considering using a company vehicle or claiming business mileage these questions will include:

  • Is a company car worth it?
  • How does a company car work?
  • How much tax do you pay on a company car?
  • Can you use a company car for personal use?
  • How much does a company car cost to run?
  • How to work out mileage costs?
  • Can you claim mileage on a company car?
  • How to report personal use of company vehicle?

In this guide, we’ll consider these and look at how much tax will I pay on a company car. In addition, we’ll look at what you can save when you use your private vehicle for business journeys.

Know what you can claim

Knowing what you can claim for can be a bit confusing when you use your car for business reasons. Therefore, this guide aims to make this clearer for you.

Most importantly, when you’re a sole trader, there’s no actual concept of a business car. Indeed, this is because you and your business are the same legal entity. On the other hand, when you have your own company, both you and your company are two separate legal entities. Therefore, when you have your own contractor limited company, it can own a vehicle and provide this to you as an employee of your company.

When we consider is mileage taxable, providing you only claim for genuine business journeys, your mileage allowances is tax-deductible. 

Company car versus mileage allowance -mileage rates when using own car for work mileage 

For sole traders 

Sole traders have a choice of two methods regarding how to calculate mileage for taxes. Therefore, as a sole trader, we show below how you can work out how to claim mileage on taxes, when you use your own car for your work journeys:

  • The first option is the `mileage method.’ To clarify, you can use this method if you have never claimed capital allowances on your car. What’s more, this method gathers the total business mileage for their business travels during the tax year. As a result, you can convert it into mileage allowances by claiming at the HM Revenue & Customs’ (HMRC) approved mileage rates. Basically, 45 pence per mile is claimable for the first 10,000 miles you travel in the tax year (6 April to 5 April). In addition, after this, 25 pence can then be claimed for each mile after that; or
  • The second choice is the `actual cost method.’ What’s more, this way of calculating what you can claim takes the total business mileage and compares it against the total overall mileage. Indeed, once you have done this, you can calculate a percentage of the total miles related to your business journeys. Next, you can take this percentage and apply it against the total cost of all your car’s various running costs. As a result, you can calculate the proportion of your vehicle running costs that you can claim as a business expense.

To sum up, whichever choice you make from the above, your claim will reduce your taxable profits. As a result, this’ll also reduce the tax and NI you pay on these. 

For contractors     

First, most contractors will tend to work via their own company or perhaps via an umbrella company. Therefore, you can go ahead claiming mileage on taxes when you use your private vehicle to travel to work. Furthermore, you’ll claim your company mileage allowances under HMRC’s approved mileage rates. In turn, this’ll enable your company to pay you a private car mileage allowance.

As above, the mileage reimbursement rate for independent contractors is 45p for the first 10,000 miles travelled in the tax year. However, the rate then changes to 25p per mile for each mile thereafter. What’s more, when you go ahead and calculate mileage claim, these rates intend to compensate you as the employee for your overall car running costs for the vehicle. In fact, this’ll include your contractor fuel expenses, any repairs and maintenance, road tax, and insurance. Therefore, if you’re running your own company and you’re using your private vehicle for business you can claim mileage on taxes. As a result, your company can reimburse your company mileage at the above rates. In turn, this’ll save company tax.

What’s more, there’s two other car-related costs that you can claim when using a private vehicle for business journeys. Indeed, if you claim private car mileage for business journeys, these are:

  • Parking fees.
  • Road tolls.

In summary, when you use your private car for business journeys, the company will save Corporation Tax (CT). This CT saving is at 19% or 25% on the company mileage in your private car. In addition, the company can also save CT on any parking fees and road tolls. 

Company car versus mileage -a look at company vehicles 

Initial considerations

First, with the rising benefits for company vehicles in recent years, some good contractor company car tax advice it’s usually no longer beneficial to run a car through your business. Basically, as part of our company car v mileage for a private car comparison, this is especially the case where the vehicle has a large engine size and high CO2. Therefore, because of this, many refer to such vehicles as `gas-guzzlers’.

However, it can be beneficial to run a car though your business if it’s a tax-efficient company vehicle. Basically, for it to be tax-efficient, the car should have low CO2 emissions. What’s more, it can be even more beneficial if your car is a hybrid or electric-type vehicle. Most importantly, most electric cars and some hybrid vehicles are tax-efficient company vehicles. Therefore, cars with electric power are becoming more popular daily, and a plug-in hybrid car is another popular option.

Low emissions

Any `normal’ vehicle that doesn’t have ultra-low emissions is more expensive to run as a company car. As a result, such a car won’t be a tax-efficient vehicle. Therefore, the type of car is a key consideration when you’re looking to use a company vehicle for the future.

Company vehicle considerations

As part of this mileage reimbursement vs company car comparison, when a contractor considers looking for a company vehicle, it’s also worth looking at the latest electric and hybrid cars. Most importantly, if a contractor’s car is electric, these types of vehicles are very tax-efficient. However, for those contractors’ cars that are electric, they can be expensive to purchase.

Many contractors will ask are company cars worth it in terms of the additional tax. These come in addition to extra reporting that you have to do for a business car. Therefore, it’s worth running this past your accountant if you’re considering purchasing a company vehicle. Indeed, they’ll be able to work out if your choice of vehicle will or won’t be a tax-efficient company car for you. As a result, your accountant can also help you to choose an option that fits your circumstances. In conclusion, if your accountant calculates the best option, you should not end up paying any extra taxes.

Today, the way that you pay tax on business cars depends on:

  • The level of CO2 that the car emits from petrol and diesel cars; and
  • The electric range for electric cars.

You can use a company car tax calculator to work out any benefits and see if it’ll be tax-efficient. Alternatively, you can work these out yourself or via your accountant. Therefore, let’s now take a look at this more closely.

If you’re thinking about a company vehicle and claiming mileage on company car instead of being provided with fuel by your employer, generally you can do this. When you do, you won’t have a fuel benefit. However, the mileage rates are set by HMRC and are lower than the ones shown above for private vehicles.

Road tax for company cars

When you own a car in the UK, you must pay road tax annually. What’s more, this charge is based on the CO2 emissions of your vehicle. In addition, when you buy a new car in the UK, there’s a fee of £55 if you register and tax a car for the first time with DVLA.

It’s key to note that there’s currently no vehicle excise duty (road tax) on electric cars. Therefore, if you buy an electric vehicle:

  • You’ll still have to tax your vehicle from the outset; and
  • Then renew your electric car road tax every 12 months, even though there is nothing to pay.

If you buy a hybrid car, the road tax rate will depend on the year of registration and CO2 emissions. What’s more, further information can be found online regarding your vehicle type.

Company car vs mileage allowance -company car tax explained 

A contractor company vehicle

If we consider how do company cars work, then indeed you should give careful consideration around the company car tax rules. Indeed, all company car drivers should do this before they go ahead with a company vehicle. Therefore, once you have done your research. you can look into what sort of vehicle you could buy or lease through your business. What’s more, if you go ahead, you’ll be arranging for your company to provide you with a business car. As a result, when you do, the company car expenses will be paid for by the company and it’ll save CT on the various company car running costs. Meanwhile, although depreciation on the actual vehicle cost is claimed in the accounts, the company will save CT on the car cost through Capital Allowances. Therefore, these, in turn, are applied in the company’s CT computations.

When we investigate how does company car tax work, if the company allows you to use the car for private car mileage journeys, there’s a tax cost. Therefore, because of the private miles in company car, the tax cost for company car personal mileage is based upon what we call Benefits in Kind (BiK). The benefit in kind (BiK tax) is what results in the company car tax (UK). Therefore, when working out the benefit, we’ll need to know how to calculate company car tax.

Calculate the benefits and tax on company car

HMRC need the fuel type and other details of your vehicle when you report the benefits to them on form P11D. Therefore, as mentioned, when we look at how to work out company car tax, this is calculated on the BIK. Indeed, when we work out the car’s P11D benefit in kind, this is based on either:

  • The car’s CO2 emissions when it’s a regular petrol or diesel car, and most hybrid cars. CO2 represents the amount of carbon dioxide that the vehicle emits. Therefore, once the CO2 emissions figure is known, you can calculate the percentage rate. Certainly, in turn, this is applied to the car’s list price to calculate the BIK.
  • The car’s electrical range if it’s an electric car. Therefore, once the electrical range is known, you can calculate the percentage rate. Certainly, in turn, this is applied to the car’s list price to calculate the BIK.

The benefit percentage company car rates that apply can be found in a company car tax table from HMRC. Please see the section below on `Company car vs mileage allowance -the company car tax bands and BIK rates.’

Company and personal taxes

As the director/employee who’s provided with the company vehicle, you’ll pay tax on the benefit via your tax code, which is applied to your annual salary. Meanwhile, the employer will pay National Insurance on the benefit. Therefore, how can you determine the amount of company vehicle tax or BiK tax you’ll pay?

  • BIK is taxable on the employee at their highest tax rate (the tax bands are 20%, 40% or 45%). As a result, the BIK is included in their tax code that applies to their salary.
  • The BIK is taxable on the employer as Class 1A National Insurance(NI) at a rate of 13.8%. The rate in 2022/23 was 14.53% due to a mixture of rates as the government increased the rate in Spring 2022 then reverted on the change in Autumn of that year.

To sum up, a company car will save CT on the company vehicle running costs and actual car purchase price (under Capital Allowances). However, the company and the director will also incur company vehicle tax/NI on the BIK. Therefore, we’ll look at how to work out and calculate business car tax compared to using your private car.

A comparison of company car vs mileage allowance in private car

Now, we’ll take a look at using a company vehicle or mileage reimbursement for your private vehicle for business journeys.

The BiK rates 

The current company car BIK rates start at:

  • 2% for electric cars.
  • A rate of 23% for the greenest hybrids.
  • 25% for any car with 100 g/km CO2.

From 14%, the bands rise in 1% increments up to a maximum of 37%. What’s more, diesel models are subject to a 4% supplement, should they not meet RDE2 tests.

Company car vs mileage allowance -the company car tax bands and BIK rates

As part of this company car tax guide, HMRC have a table which shows how the percentage BIK rates vary with vehicle CO2 and electric-only range. Indeed, this represents petrol, diesel, hybrid and electric-related BIK rates for the tax years 2022-2025. What’s more, there’s a 4% supplement for diesel cars however, diesel-hybrids, the 4% diesel surcharge doesn’t apply.

How to calculate BIK

Car fuel benefit £27,800 in 2023/24 x the appropriate percentage.
Van benefit £3,960 in 2023/24 .
Van fuel benefit £757 in 2023/24.

Example of mileage in your private car v company car tax comparison for 2023/24

2017 BMW 4 Series 2.0TD M Sport Gran Coupe 5d Auto 1995CC Company car (£) Private car (£)
CT savings:
The company car running costs:
Fuel for the car 2,400
Repairs of the car 1,000
Insurance costs 500
Road Tax costs 200
Class 1A National Insurance 2,327
The Capital allowances on the vehicle list price 37,155 x 18% 6,688
Company mileage on business -27,000 miles:
10,000 miles at 45p 4,500
17,000 miles at 25p 4,250
Total costs 13,115 8,750
CT saved at a rate of 19% 2,492 1,663
Company car tax:
2017 BMW 4 Series 2.0TD M Sport Gran Coupe 5d Auto 1995CC. The CO2 emissions are 114 CO2
114 CO2 is equivalent to 27% of the list price of treating the car as a benefit in kind.
List price 37,155 x 27% 10,032
Car fuel 25,300 x 27% 6,831
Total benefits in kind 16,863
Basic rate taxpayer Higher rate taxpayer
The tax on the contractor at an income tax rate of 20% 3,373
Tax on the contractor at an income tax rate of 40% 6,745
The Class 1A National Insurance at 13.8% 2,327 2,327
Total taxes on the company vehicle 5,700 9,072
The overall tax savings for the company/individual:
Corporation Tax savings 2,492 2,492
The Taxes on benefits in kind -5,700 -9,072
Therefore, the overall tax savings (costs) for the company/individual are -3,208 -6,580

Summary of result of the above example

As you can see in the above company car vs personal car calculations, there’s overall tax costs for the company vehicle. On the other hand, there’s overall tax savings of £1,663 on the mileage cost for the personal car. This example is based on a BMW 4 Series 1995CC. However, when you run the calculations with an electric car the company vehicle option will be much more favourable.

If you’d like to run your own figures to see the outcome for company vehicle vs mileage reimbursement, you can search online for a company car vs personal car calculator. When you do this, you can compare company cars and also compare company car tax outcomes to see how tax-efficient it is. 

Contractor company vehicle and company car tax -conclusion 

In the above Company car versus mileage comparison, we now have the results. To sum up, as you can see, in this example, to run the BMW through your company, how much tax you’ll pay will depend on your income tax bracket. As a result, the overall tax bill would be £3,373 in business car tax costs per annum if you’re a basic rate taxpayer. On the other hand, if you’re a higher-rate taxpayer, it’ll cost you £6,745 in tax costs.

In contrast, you’ll make overall annual company tax savings of £1,663 if you keep the car as a private vehicle and claim company mileage allowances. The company will also reimburse the mileage allowances (£8,750 in this example) to the director tax-free. As a result, this reduces the amount of your drawings that are taxable income.

In conclusion, the result and advice in this example shows that you are considerably worse off running the BMW through your company due to the high CO2.

Therefore, you should calculate the tax position for your car, to see how tax-efficient it is. To assist here, you can find a director company car tax calculator and a mileage claim calculator (HMRC) online.

Other considerations

Company car vs mileage allowance -company car mileage rates

Instead of claiming for contractor fuel expenses (and being taxed on the fuel benefit) for a business car, there’s also an option to claim for a company car mileage rate by using the official HMRC rates. Basically, these are known as the HMRC Advisory Fuel Rates and they’re the official HMRC mileage rates (company car). Therefore, when you use the official mileage allowances for company cars, just like with a personal car, when you claim for a mileage allowance (company car):

  • Your business can reimburse the company car mileage allowance amounts to you.
  • The company will save tax on the company car business mileage. 

The official rates for mileage for a business vehicle are lower than the HMRC mileage rates for private cars. Indeed, this is because they re-compensate the individual for the fuel costs, rather than all the car running costs. Therefore, when you run a company vehicle, you can make a company car mileage claim each time you travel on business under these rates.

Hire car option

A further option in respect of a company vehicle for a contractor is to consider car leasing. In the same vein, with the company owning the vehicle, when it comes to a contractor car lease though your business there’ll be a benefit in kind. Once again, this is based on the same method, by applying a percentage rate to the vehicle’s list price. Therefore, you should look for a tax-efficient company vehicle as explained earlier.

Under the contractor lease car option, a company can claim the hire costs as an expense (as opposed to claiming the cost of the car). In addition, the business can reclaim 50% of the VAT on the hire costs if it’s VAT registered and operates under the standard/normal VAT scheme.

Going for the hire car option in the above example will result in a similar outcome: being worse off by hiring the car through your company. However, when you hire a tax-efficient company car such as an electric vehicle, you’ll be better off in terms of tax costs and savings.

Travel by bicycle instead

We’ve written about using a bicycle or motorcycle for your work journeys. Basically, in this guide, we look at the considerations between company-owned and privately owned bikes. What’s more, this is a good read if you’re considering using this method of travel.

Final thoughts

Today, when we consider company car versus mileage allowance, most contractors run their vehicle as a private car. As a result, they can claim business mileage for their private contractor cars through their company. Indeed, when you’re a UK contractor, you may wish to consider tax-efficient company cars for directors. Consequently, if you do, it’s likely you’ll look at electric or hybrid vehicles or a vehicle with low CO2 emissions. Finally, in our comparison of business car or mileage reimbursement, of the contractors that do have a business car, many will have these types of vehicles as they’re tax-efficient.

After you consider company car vs mileage allowance, you may decide to go ahead with a company vehicle. Therefore, the next decision is whether to buy this outright, on hire purchase, or go for an electric car lease through limited company. Indeed, under both scenarios there’ll be a BiK tax you’ll pay, and a company tax saving. However, if you decide to run a vehicle through your company, it’s best to look for tax-efficient company cars first. Finally, in today’s world very few contractors run a `gas-guzzler’ petrol or diesel model. In conclusion, this is because the tax repercussions aren’t worth it under the current tax system.

Link to Contractor Advice UK group on

LinkedIn    https://www.linkedin.com/groups/4660081/

Published On: January 4th, 2024 / Categories: Expenses /

Share This Guide, Choose Your Platform!

Leave A Comment